Townsend Security Data Privacy Blog

Enterprise Key Management System (KMS) vs Cloud Key Service (KMS, Key Vault)

Posted by Patrick Townsend on Mar 16, 2020 3:38:00 PM

I am often asked about public cloud provider encryption key services like AWS KMS and Azure Key Vault. There are substantial differences between an Enterprise Key Management System (we have one) and the key services provided by Amazon and Microsoft (and Google has one, too). Enterprise Key Management Systems provide dedicated, full lifecycle key management under your exclusive control. Cloud key services provide a small subset of encryption key management support, in a non-dedicated, multi-tenant, shared environment. 

Perhaps the best way to show the differences is in a side-by-side table comparing our Alliance Key Manager for AWS and Azure, and Cloud Service Provider (CSP) key services:

Feature

Alliance Key Manager

Cloud Key Service

     

Standards

   

FIPS 140-2 Compliant

Yes

Back end only

OASIS KMIP compliant

Yes

No

     

Operational

   

Dedicated control

Yes

No, Shared Custody

Cross cloud

Yes

No

Mirror keys to on-premise

Yes

No

On-premise to cloud seamless migration

Yes

No

Backup off cloud

Yes

No

Key mirroring across regions/zones

Yes

No

Migrate to HSM

Yes

No

Automatic failover across regions/zones

Yes

No

     

VMware and Kubernetes

   

VMware encrypted VM support

Yes, certified

No

VMware encrypted vSAN support

Yes, certified

No

VMware vTPM support

Yes

No

     

Database & Application

   

SQL Server TDE support

Yes

No

MongoDB Enterprise Advanced support

Yes

No

MySQL Enterprise support

Yes

No

IBM DB2 support

Yes

No

Drupal

Yes

No

     

SDKs

   

Java

Yes

Yes

.NET (C#)

Yes

No

Python

Yes

Yes

C/C++

Yes

Yes

PHP

Yes

No

Perl

Yes

No

RPG

Yes

No

COBOL

Yes

No

 

Download Alliance Key Manager

Topics: Encryption Key Management